Hitler Laughing: Comedy in the Third Reich

Product Information

Think of today's dictators and would-be dictators, in any country, and you can spot all the juvenile qualities that Chaplin identified: the fetish for photo opportunities, the lavish lifestyles, the policy flip-flops and the crackpot schemes, the self-aggrandising parades and the chests full of medals: Billy Gilbert's Herring, ie. Although some reviewers criticized the film for its heavy-handed message (13), for the most part reception was excellent; and, since its release, the film has become a comedy classic. Then in 1940 came The Great Dictator, which, by deploying a star as big as Charlie Chaplin, seemed to give everyone a licence to laugh at Hitler. Chaplin later said that had he known the extent of the Nazis’ barbarity, he would not have burlesqued them; their crimes were simply too immense for comedy, however trenchant. On opening night, at least one audience in Berlin chuckled when the acting coach — also named Adolf, last name Gruenbaum, middle name Israel — dressed Hitler in a track suit and made him do deep breathing exercises, and later, when Gruenbaum punches Hitler and knocks him out.

He chose to join the army, and ended up being awarded an Iron Cross for his actions on the Eastern Front.On the one hand, the abusive physical humour associated with the Stooges trivializes the bullying or goon-like behaviour associated with Hitler’s Sturmabteilung or SA. In fact, weirdly enough, in 1933, Hitler’s personal secretary, Ernst “Putzi” Hanfstaengl, published a book of Hitler caricatures consisting of mocking images of Hitler taken from various publications around the world. To Be Or Not To Be (Ernst Lubitsch, 1942), one of the best-known comedies set during the Third Reich besides The Great Dictator, mixes humour and drama to bring viewers into the tragedy then occurring in Europe. According to biographer Jürgen Trimborn, much of the film was inspired by a screening of Leni Riefenstahl's pro-Hitler documentary, Triumph of the Will, at the New York Museum of Modern Art. This transgressive commemorative practice values the power of laughter as liberating and as a means of survival in the face of death.

The plot is far-fetched but the character is human and complex, not the usual portrayal of Hitler as monster or clown. The younger generation blamed their elders for the denial of the Nazi past and at this time it was impossible to joke about Hitler”. At the beginning extra3 used to get regular complaints from viewers, but their number has decreased over the years. Moses Horwitz, better known as Moe Howard, the Boss in the series The Three Stooges, wore a faux Hitler-like moustache and slapped around his sidekicks in You Natzy Spy! Hitler, at the window of the Reich Chancellery, receives an ovation on the evening of his inauguration as chancellor, 30 January 1933.Hitler carefully monitored his public persona, studying photographs and film of his speeches, and taking lessons in public presentation. Britain's appeasement policy kept going until March 1939, and the US didn't enter World War Two until December 1941, a year after The Great Dictator was released, so when Chaplin was scripting and shooting the film – his first proper talkie – colleagues at the studio he co-owned were afraid that no government would let it be seen. that] expresses the laugher's sudden discovery of his own momentary superiority over the person at whom he is laughing.

As his urbane sidekick and Goebbels substitute, Garbitsch (Henry Daniell), says: "Violence against the Jews might take the public's mind off its stomach. Many of the letters singled out the satire programmes: “That you also brought us humour made the unbearable bearable for us,” wrote one listener, while another expressed admiration for “how well you understand the soul of the people”.

After all, laughing at one’s adversaries is a received and accepted antidote to dealing with outside threats.